Actor Colton Haynes often plays the straight man: stoic, serious, or youthfully determined, Haynes’ roles often define the modern-day protagonist, even when he’s part of the secondary cast. With that in mind, Haynes’ Halloween activities couldn’t be any farther away from his on-screen personas. For over half a decade, Haynes’ creative costumes have been making headlines, and this has served to propel the actor to take on even crazier personas every year. While he’s often found in the spandex of a certain red vigilante, Haynes often opts for female characters and over-the-top makeup.