Did Caleb Williams Have The Worst #1 Pick Debut Ever? Not Even Close

Caleb Williams came into the 2024 season with a lot of hype. Probably too much. The NFL has a bad tendency to raise unfair expectations of young players in their first seasons. Williams was a star at USC, winning a Heisman and putting up crazy numbers. He also had the bad luck of arriving a year after C.J. Stroud had one of the best rookie seasons a quarterback has ever produced. That put a lot of pressure on the #1 overall pick, and it seemed to show in his debut against the Tennessee Titans.

He finished 14 of 29 for 93 yards. His frustrating afternoon was characterized by inaccurate passes and an inability to handle pressure. Many had inevitable knee-jerk reactions, wondering if they may have overestimated Williams’ ability. This has to be the worst debut a #1 overall pick has ever had, right? After going back to look at every quarterback who has been in that spot since 2000, the simple answer is not even close.

Michael Vick

• 4-of-12 for 32 yards and 1 TD

David Carr

• 10-of-22 for 145 yards, 2 TDs, and 1 INT

Carson Palmer (didn’t start until second season)

• 18-of-27 for 248 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT

Eli Manning

• 17-of-37 for 162 yards, 1 TD, 2 INTs

Alex Smith

• 9-of-23 for 74 yards and 4 INTs

JaMarcus Russell

• 23-of-31 for 224 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT

Matthew Stafford

• 16-of-37 for 205 yards and 3 INTs

Sam Bradford

• 32-of-55 for 255 yards, 1 TD, 3 INTs

Cam Newton

• 24-of-37 for 422 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT

Andrew Luck

• 23-of-45 for 309 yards, 1 TD, 3 INTs

Jameis Winston

• 16-of-33 for 210 yards, 2 TDs, 2 INTs

Jared Goff

• 17-of-31 for 134 yards

Baker Mayfield

• 21-of-41 for 295 yards, 2 TDs, 2 INTs

Kyler Murray

• 29-of-54 for 308 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT

Joe Burrow

• 23-of-36 for 193 yards and 1 INT

Trevor Lawrence

• 28-of-51 for 332 yards, 3 TDs, 3 INTs

Bryce Young

• 20-of-38 for 146 yards, 1 TD, and 2 INTs

Caleb Williams did nothing out of the ordinary.

Based on the results above, people would’ve thought Alex Smith and Matthew Stafford were destined to be busts. Instead, Smith reached three Pro Bowls, and Stafford will likely go to the Hall of Fame after he retires. That list doesn’t include other notable names like John Elway and Troy Aikman, who also made ugly debuts. They were omitted just because rules were different in those days. Yet the trend remains the same. Rookie quarterbacks rarely play well in their first games. Many of them don’t even play mediocre.

The key to determining whether they have the capacity to play in the NFL is how they perform as the season progresses. If they still look like that in November and December, then yeah, there is a problem. However, most tend to smooth out the kinks and start playing more efficiently. Caleb Williams deserves the same grace period. His talent didn’t magically disappear. All of the problems that showed up against Tennessee were correctable. As the game slows down for him, the execution will improve.