He condemned Robert Hur’s suggestion in his classified-documents report that he didn’t know when his son died. “How in the hell dare he,” Biden said.
The special counsel investigating Joe Biden determined in a report released Thursday that the president would not be charged with any crimes for taking classified documents to his home in Delaware in his years between the White House. Robert Hur, the former U.S. Attorney assigned to the case, also detailed in the report numerous instances when Biden appeared to have problems with his memory — and those parts of the report have drawn furious pushback from Biden and the White House.
What the special counsel said about Biden’s memory
The details of Biden’s classified-documents handling are likely to be overshadowed by Hur’s observations about the president’s memory. In several different passages, Hur paints a picture of Biden as not only forgetful but deeply unaware of when key events in his life took place. Polls have consistently shown that Biden’s age is the American public’s biggest concern about him.
Hur, a former Trump-nominated U.S. Attorney, writes that during interviews with a ghostwriter in 2017 and with Hur’s office in 2023, Biden seemed confused on a number of occasions. In one interview, Biden did not recall exactly when he was vice-president and could not remember the year of his son Beau’s death. Hur also writes, in language that appears to editorialize, that Biden was “hazy when describing the Afghanistan debate that was once so important to him.”
This from the Hur report: "Mr Biden's memory also appeared to have significant limitations...."
— Frank Thorp V (@frankthorp) February 8, 2024
“He did not remember, even within several years, when his son Beau died,” the report states: https://t.co/j50rE280hT pic.twitter.com/P0O3tV8y2E
Hur even suggests that Biden’s “diminished faculties and faulty memory,” in his words, was one of the reasons he chose not to prosecute the president. “Based on our direct interactions with and observations of him, he is someone for whom many jurors will want to identify reasonable doubt,” Hur wrote. “It would be difficult to convince a jury that they should convict him — by then a former president well into his eighties — of a serious felony that requires a mental state of willfulness.”
Hur concludes that at a possible trial, “Biden would likely present himself to a jury, as he did during our interview of him, as a sympathetic, well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory.” It was a line that was immediately seized upon by Republicans to prove their point that the president is too old and doddering to be reelected.
Biden refuted and rebuked Hur’s claims
Both Biden and his team were reportedly livid about the language of the report. Richard Sauber, a special counsel to the president, and Bob Bauer, his personal counsel, wrote in a letter to Hur that “We do not believe that the report’s treatment of President Biden’s memory is accurate or appropriate.” They added that “the report uses highly prejudicial language to describe a commonplace occurrence among witnesses: a lack of recall of years-old events.”
In a statement, Biden himself noted that he sat for “five hours of in-person interviews over two days on October 8 and 9 of last year, even though Israel had just been attacked on October 7 and I was in the middle of handling an international crisis.” Privately, Biden was reportedly incensed:
NEW w/ @MariannaReports: Biden blew up in a private meeting with some House Democrats earlier Thursday.
— Tyler Pager (@tylerpager) February 9, 2024
When he was asked how he was doing, he said, “How the fuck could I forget the day my son died? Of course I remember everything,” per two people familiar with his comments.
On Thursday night, Biden held a press conference to address the contents of the report, including the questions it raised regarding his memory. In particular, Biden took issue with the claim that he didn’t know when his son died. “How in the hell dare he raise that,” the president said:
President Biden: "There's some attention paid to some language in the report about my recollection of events. There's even reference that I don't remember when my son died. How in the hell dare he raise that?"
— CSPAN (@cspan) February 9, 2024
He adds, "I don’t need anyone to remind me when he passed away." pic.twitter.com/ywKQDhABM5
“I’m well meaning, and I’m an elderly man, and I know what the hell I’m doing. I’ve been president and I put this country back on its feet,” he also said. And he joked about his age and memory with reporters as well.
Q: "How bad is your memory? Can you continue as president?"
— CSPAN (@cspan) February 9, 2024
President Biden: "My memory is so bad I let you speak...my memory is fine." pic.twitter.com/Le4DpoqP7H
Then later, while responding to a question from a reporter about the war in Gaza, he mixed up the names of the presidents of Egypt and Mexico — which is the kind of gaffe Biden has been making for decades.
What the Hur report says about Biden’s handling of classified documents, and why he hasn’t been charged
Hur found that Biden had taken home “classified documents about military and foreign policy in Afghanistan” as well as handwritten notebooks on national-security and foreign-policy issues that involved “sensitive intelligence sources and methods.” The FBI found these documents in the basement, garage, and office of Biden’s home in Wilmington in a voluntary search last January.
Hur declined to prosecute Biden for the retention of classified documents, citing the president’s cooperation with investigators. Donald Trump, who was charged with willful retention of national-defense information, did not cooperate in several attempts to recover the material — to the point that Trump was also charged for making false statements and conspiracy to obstruct justice.
Hur’s report also states that “the evidence does not establish Mr. Biden’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.” Several of the documents were handwritten notes related to classified information provided in the daily presidential brief and National Security Council meetings. Hur also states that Biden provided some classified material to his ghostwriter for his memoir Promise Me, Dad. In one recording from February 2017 obtained during the investigation, Biden told his ghostwriter that he “just found all the classified stuff downstairs” at a house he was renting in Virginia.
Hur stated that this recording was the strongest evidence for potential prosecution, but that it would be unlikely for a jury to convict him. National Archives and Records Administration officials have stated that members of every administration since Reagan have mishandled documents in some capacity. Hur wrote that vice-presidents and presidents often get used to keeping documents at home. (The audio of Biden discussing classified documents in the basement was recorded just weeks after Trump’s inauguration.) Hur also stated that the “badly damaged box surrounded by household detritus” in Biden’s garage suggests that he could have forgotten about some of the classified documents, rather than withheld them intentionally.
How Trump has responded
After the report was released, Donald Trump released a statement decrying the Justice Department’s decisions to prosecute him but not Biden, claiming Biden handled documents in a much worse way than he had. Soon after, on Truth Social, Trump wrote that “Biden took the Documents in his ‘mental primetime’” but otherwise just echoed his previous statement. He later began reposting other people’s messages highlighting the details in the report about Biden’s memory.
Trump advisers were not expecting Special Counsel Hur to charge Biden over classified docs but they were hoping to score political win — the report describing Biden as a “well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory” is being seen as maybe the best outcome
— Hugo Lowell (@hugolowell) February 8, 2024
This post has been updated.
Related
