Speaking Wednesday night in Phoenix, Donald Trump promised his audience that a massive wall-building program, a brutal crackdown on the undocumented population, unilateral abrogation of trade deals, and new restrictions on legal immigration would usher in a new era of American safety and broad-based prosperity.
When he stopped talking, the Rolling Stones’ “You Can’t Always Get What You Want” played. Because, in case you somehow don’t get it, none of this is even remotely true or workable.
He is maybe aware of this, and if he isn’t surely some of the people in his orbit are, but for whatever reason he doesn’t care and clearly isn’t going to stop saying what he’s saying.
After a weeks-long flirtation with “softening” his position on immigration that culminated with a surprisingly banal joint press conference with Mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto, Donald Trump reminded us on Wednesday night that Donald Trump is Donald Trump — and that’s not going to change.
Trump, to review, has no experience in elected or appointed government office. Nor does he have any interest in or knowledge of American public policy. But he did once say Barack Obama was born in Kenya and become a huge celebrity in Republican Party politics. He followed that up with the claim that the Mexican government is deliberately sending murderers and rapists to the United States.
That combination of racist attacks on the president of the United States and racist attacks on the entire Mexican-American population were good enough to vault him to the top of the GOP primary polling. They delivered him the nomination. And they’re clearly not enough to deliver him the presidency of the United States.
This turn of events has sparked a months-long bout of wishful thinking in Republican Party circles. “He’s not a policy guy,” one Republican Senate staffer once told me, as part of a loopy explanation that Trump would actually be a fine president because he’ll be so indifferent to policy matters that other people will just make all the decisions about everything.
The pivot — the softening — whatever you want to call it, is just part and parcel of them same wishful thinking. That’s the moral of Wednesday night’s speech. There are no hidden depths to Trump. There’s just fear and demagoguery and nonsense. David Duke loved it.
Excellent speech by Donald Trump tonight. Deport criminal aliens, end catch and release, enforce immigration laws & America First.
— David Duke (@DrDavidDuke) September 1, 2016
Trump portrays a world in which crime is skyrocketing (it isn’t) and illegal immigration is skyrocketing (it isn’t) and skyrocketing immigration explains skyrocketing crimes (it doesn’t because neither of those things are happening). He says he can build a 1,600-mile wall across the southern border at a reasonable cost (he can’t) and he says that he will get Mexico to pay for its construction (he can’t). He says immigrants are depressing average Americans’ wages (they aren’t) and that Hillary Clinton has a plan for open borders (she doesn’t).
Trump is, on some level, surely aware that he is bullshitting. He worked in the real estate development industry and knows better than you or I do that the logistical requirements to undertake the wall project as he’s defined it are mind-boggling. At times, he’s even considered owning up to that fact.
I was told Trump & his advisers are concerned about making the wall feasible and ensuring it doesn't add to the budget deficit.
— Sara Murray (@SaraMurray) September 1, 2016
Portions of the US-Mexico border, for example, run through roadless uninhabited desert. To build a wall there, you would need to build roads to transport the material, build places for the workers to live, hire other workers to maintain the colony, and somehow pay everyone enough to make it worth their while to go live in a temporary camp in an uninhabited desert. It’s self-evidently absurd and of course Mexico isn’t going to pay for it.
Trump’s passion, however, isn’t for the details of border security or immigration economics. It’s for lurid tales of bloodshed. He opened the speech with long descriptions of a handful of people who’ve been murdered by illegal immigrants, and he closed it with testimonials from relatives of the deceased. Lurid fantasies about avenging these crime victims have dominated much of Trump’s “thinking” about politics ever since he made a splash with paid newspaper ads urging the execution of five young men who turn out to have been falsely accused of murder.
A normal person would feel ashamed to have once loudly and publicly advocating for the killing of five people for a crime they didn’t commit. Not Trump. “These young men do not exactly have the pasts of angels,” he wrote at the time. (Trump has bragged about punching his music teacher which, I guess, is what the angels do.) The one hint of moderation is that he said we should deport Hillary Clinton for unspecified crimes, which is much more restrained than earlier calls to have her locked up or maybe killed.
Trump is a person, not a cartoon. He can do a calm, controlled speech or even a calm, controlled week. But there is no calm, controlled, responsible version of Donald Trump the politician who can mount a sustained presidential campaign or who could serve for a sustained period of time in the Oval Office. As a political figure, Trump has always been a race-baiting, fear-mongering demagogue and that’s not going to change. If that’s what you’re looking for in a president, then you’ll love the Trump administration. If you find it off-putting but you’re really into tax cuts, he’ll probably throw you those too.
But it’s long past time to stop expecting someone to pull off the Trump mask and find some kind of earnest, responsible politician lurking underneath. The Trump we saw Wednesday night is the Trump who accepted the Republican nomination six weeks ago is the Trump who descended the Trump Tower escalators in Manhattan a year ago.
Trump is Trump.
