In Reply In September 2024, a US appeals court struck down California’s prohibition on firearms in health care settings, citing the Supreme Court’s new requirement that modern gun laws be evaluated based on whether they are consistent with historical tradition rather than their ability to address the threat and reality of gun violence. Under this “originalist” approach, whether hospitals qualify as “sensitive places” where guns can be prohibited turns on whether judges believe hospitals to be sufficiently similar to places where guns have historically been prohibited.
