The characterization, by Donald Trump and his surrogates, of Vice President Kamala Harris’s alleged failings concerning border security is an amalgam of willful ignorance and bad faith. The many lies and half-truths are often spewed by Brandon Judd, the president of the Border Patrol Union who sometimes “opens” for the former President at some of his many rallies. Judd, it seems, is much more interested in parroting the Trump orthodoxy on Border Security than serving as a leader with the integrity that the men and women of Customs and Border Protection (CBP) deserve.
Unlike Trump and his cronies, The Biden-Harris Administration has known all along that no matter how many physical or legal barriers are erected in the name of border security, migrants will continue to seek asylum in the United States as long as conditions in their home countries are intolerable. President Biden wisely charged Vice President Harris with leading the diplomatic efforts (not “Border Czar”) to help reduce crime, violence, poverty and corruption in those nations responsible for the greatest percentage of migrants… and she made significant progress.
While Republicans were admiring the “Wall”, mugging for the cameras in their boots and jeans, Kamala Harris was doing the hard, time-consuming, frustrating, behind-the-scenes diplomacy. Working with the Northern Triangle countries of Central America, she was able to enlist the aid of over 50 American companies who invested $5 billion in those countries. Following this, migration from the targeted nations dropped by 50-60%. Conditions in the Northern Triangle nations are not going to improve over night. What is required is a long-term, multi-national effort to eliminate those factors that cause desperate people to flee their homeland. Fortunately, a future Harris administration understands that.
Trump relishes blaming Vice President Harris for what he asserts is chaos at the border and I, for one, agree that there is much to be done to improve unacceptable conditions at our borders. The facts are, however, that the Biden-Harris Administration has made significant strides in improving border security even without the vital resources that would have been deployed under the bipartisan border bill; resources that would have drastically improved both the force strength and the effectiveness of CBP.
The Biden-Harris Administration instituted tough restrictions on asylum claims that have, arguably, been instrumental in reducing illegal crossings to their lowest level since 2020. The Administration also deserves considerable credit for the recent evisceration of the leadership of the notorious Sinaloa Cartel with the arrest of cartel leaders “El Mayo” Garcia and Joaquin Guzman Loera, son of the infamous “El Chapo” Guzman. Additionally, in June 2021, under the leadership of Vice President Harris, Task Force Alpha, a law enforcement task force was established with the cooperation of Mexico and the Northern Triangle nations to combat smuggling and human trafficking.
Border Security is one of the most difficult, divisive, politically fraught and complicated national security issues facing our nation. It is irresponsible, in the extreme, for members of either party to use the border and its many related issues as a political weapon. But that is where we are today; particularly as it pertains to the GOP, its platform and the rantings of its presidential candidate and his surrogates.
Instead of focusing on meaningful, long-term solutions to a complex problem, like Vice President Harris has been doing, Trump and his minions engage in “Border Security Theater.” Over the course of the past six years, Trump and his surrogates (including the recently selected ice presidential candidate J.D. Vance) have periodically flocked to the Southwest border to stage photo ops in front of Trump’s “Wall.” Continuation of the supremely ineffective wall and the mass deportation of migrants are what pass, these days, for the heart of Trump’s “Border Policy.” The approach is breathtaking in its cynicism and emptiness.
In a feat of ethical gymnastics truly worthy of a gold medal, it is riveting to watch Brandon Judd laud the former President for his inspired leadership on border security, all the while knowing that Trump bullied the GOP leadership into torpedoing the first tough, bi-partisan and meaningful border bill in generations. It was a bill that he and his union enthusiastically endorsed. That’s some chutzpah.
The nation was finally on the cusp of being able to bring meaningful change to our badly broken border and immigration programs, including more CBP Agents, advanced technology for detecting concealed contraband, more immigration judges, and much else. Trump, of course, initially favorable to it, had the deal killed when he realized he needed to preserve it as a campaign issue. This was unconscionable.
In November, the electorate will have a clear choice as to who is likely to bring positive, meaningful change to our troubled borders. With Trump, it will be more of the same – walls, rhetoric, threats, and bluster. With Kamala Harris, we have a chance to address the root causes driving migration and, perhaps, for the first time, focus on a permanent solution. For me, that’s an easy call.
Robert Kelly is the former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Drug Enforcement and former Deputy Chairman of the government’s Border Interdiction Committee.
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
