In recent years, McGinnis faced challenges with walking due to multiple back surgeries prompted by a hereditary condition. Despite these difficulties, his distinctive deep voice, deliberate manner, warm personality, and love for the sport endeared him to fans in his basketball-rich home state of Indiana. McGinnis forged a close connection with the audience as they witnessed his journey from an Indianapolis prep star to an unstoppable force during his singular college season at Indiana University. Eventually, he led the Indiana Pacers to clinch two championship titles.