Best hot cross bun named by Which? for Easter in taste test including Aldi and Tesco

SHOPPERS are gearing up for Easter and consumer watchdog Which? has risen to the challenge of finding the best hot cross bun.

Which? has conducted a blind taste test of supermarket own-brand buns – here are the results.

Supermarket shelves are starting to get filled with Easter treats including hot cross buns.

Many shoppers are watching the pennies at the moment amid the cost of living crisis so you want to make sure you are getting a good deal but also something that tastes nice.

Consumer watchdog Which? got its consumer panel to blind taste test own-brand hot cross buns from eight supermarkets.

They were then rated by taste and value.

Discount supermarket Aldi came out on top and was the only brand to be ranked a Which? Best Buy due to the taste.

It also happened to be the cheapest.

Meanwhile, Waitrose, which was one of the most expensive supermarkets for own-brand buns, ranked at the bottom of the list.

Here is how the supermarkets ranked from best to worst.

Aldi

The testers tried a pack of Aldi Specially Selected Luxury Fruited Hot Cross Buns.

They cost 99p per pack or 25p each, making them the cheapest in the test.

Aldi’s affordable buns proved a hit with our panel, receiving They also received high marks for their flavour, texture and aroma, with an overall score of 74%.

Morrisons

Morrisons shared second place in the taste test with Marks and Spencer.

Its Best Extra Fruity Hot Cross Buns got a score of 73%.

The testing panel said the flavour and texture was on par with Aldi, but at £1.50 a pack or 38p each, they are slightly more expensive than the discount supermarket option.

Marks & Spencer

M&S offers a pack of four Luxury Hot Cross Buns for £1.75 or 44p per pack.

They scored 73% and were among the best-rated for flavour but were the most expensive.

Co-op

Co-op’s Richly Fruited Luxury Hot Cross Bun were also rated highly, receiving 72% overall.

They were described as a “decent option” and scored well for flavour and texture.

A pack of four costs £1.50 or 38p per bun.

Asda

Shoppers can get a four-pack of Extra Fruity Hot Cross Buns from Asda for £1.50 per pack or 38p each.

Testers gave the treats a score of 70%, rating it well across the board but not on par with the top three.

Tesco

The taste testers weren’t so impressed with Tesco‘s offering.

They tried its four Extra Fruity Hot Cross Buns but didn’t like the appearance and more than half said they weren’t sweet enough.

A pack of four costs the same as Co-op and Aldi but it scored 68%.

Sainsbury’s

Sainsbury’s was the joint lowest scoring brand.

Its Fruity Hot Cross Buns cost £1.50, per pack and a third of the panel felt they lacked a good spiced flavour.

The buns scored 66%.

Waitrose

Waitrose also got a score of 66%.

At £1.65 per pack or 41p per bun, they were the second most expensive.

The panel described them as “xpensive and underwhelming vs rivals.”

Their appearance disappointed and half of the tasters thought they were too dry.

Good Housekeeping has also done its own hot cross bun taste test, see how its results compare.

Meanwhile, Greggs fans may be disappointed this year as the bakery chain won’t be selling hot cross buns.