A conditioner is the last line of defense against spilt-ends, a dry scalp, and fading color. Whether you bow before the altar of the sulfate-free co-wash or remain faithful to your local drugstore aisle, it’s likely that the conditioner you use is specific to your own hair needs and nothing short of a miracle. On Monday, we asked you to divulge your conditioner of choice and—oh boy—there was very little consensus to be found. Here are the five victors who managed to rise above the fray