A minor swap with New York that turned out about as even as can be
The White Sox dealt young center fielder Jim Delsing to the Yankees for first baseman-left fielder Bud Souchock. And by any account the deal was a draw between 0.1 WAR players. Souchock was a platoon player for the 1949 White Sox before being lost to Detroit in 1950’s Rule 5 draft and playing for a few unremarkable years with the Tigers. Meanwhile Delsing was swapped away by New York in 1950 and played all the way until 1960 in the majors.
For their careers, the difference in players was razor-thin, Delsing a 1.4 WAR veteran and Souchock logging 1.3 WAR.
In an unexpected move the White Sox named “The Brat” (Eddie Stanky) as the team’s new manager, replacing the retired Al Lopez. Stanky was an intense, obsessed man — the 60’s managerial version of Billy Martin or Earl Weaver.
Stanky knew baseball and was a genius with tactical decisions, but he was also extremely unpopular with many of his players. He imposed a curfew, dress code and a rigorous calisthenics program on the team. He would fine players (or bench them) every time they weren’t able to lay down a bunt, hit a sacrifice fly or advance runners into scoring position.
On the other hand, Stanky offered a new suit of clothes for any pitcher who threw a complete game with at least a certain number of ground ball outs. For stolen bases or taking a base into scoring position, a player would get a new pair of dress shoes.
Stanky would have winning seasons in 1966 and 1967 (nearly taking the pennant), but by early 1968 his act had grown old and he was fired, to be replaced by ... Al Lopez!
The White Sox traded former Cy Young winner Jack McDowell to the Yankees for minor-leaguer Keith Heberling and a player to be named later (the next April, New York sent outfielder Lyle Mouton to Chicago).
McDowell was the most successful pitcher in the American League between 1990 and 1994, winning a total of 73 games along with a Cy Young. He won 20 or more games twice in that span, making the All-Star team three times.
The move, which left the Sox pitching staff without its leader, proved very costly during the 1996 wild card collapse, and was done purely for financial reasons related to the labor situation that cost the team the last two months of the 1994 season.
While McDowell would be out of baseball by the turn of the century, he was still at his peak at the time of the trade, and put up 4.0 WAR for the Yankees in 1995.
After eight very successful years with the White Sox, Lance Johnson signed a four-year, $15.7 million contract with the New York Mets.
Johnson came to the White Sox in a steal of a deal in 1988 by GM Larry Himes, and hit .286 with 226 steals and superb defense during his time on the South Side. His 21.3 WAR ranks 23rd all-time among White Sox hitters, and third among center fielders, behind Chet Lemon and Johnny Mostil.
